| By Maureen O'Gara | Article Rating: |
|
| April 26, 2012 12:01 AM EDT | Reads: |
2,763 |
The judge in the Java trial told Oracle late Wednesday that it can’t assert the patent that the Patent and Trademark Office just said was valid against Google.
It’s too late, he said, although the patent part of the case won’t start until next week or whenever the jury decides the trademark infringement part it’s been hearing since April 16.
Oracle just asked if it could assert the third patent late Tuesday.
The judge said Oracle agreed to drop infringement claims on patents the PTO rejected before the trial started provided they remain rejected at the start of the trial and that’s what happened. So Oracle’s plum out of luck.
His decision reads: “The reversal came a few days too late, for the trial had already started and the dismissals with prejudice had already become effective. Oracle’s argument that the patent ‘trial’ has not yet started is wrong. There was and is one trial with three phases. The trial started on April 16. This is not only the plain meaning of the term but any other interpretation would inject great prejudice given that the parties have relied on the issues to be tried and that reliance should not be turned on its head in mid-trial. Oracle will be required to stand by its word and live with the dismissal with prejudice.”
The PTO reconsidered its so-called “final” rejection of one of the Java patents that Oracle claimed Google infringed and decided that nine of the patents claims are perfectly valid.
Apparently Oracle got wind of the PTO’s change of mind late last week and rushed in Sunday to tell the court about it.
Conveniently, the claims upheld match Oracle’s to a “T” with a little to spare, and, as FOSS Patents pointed, there’s nothing quite like the teeth of a re-examined patent.
Google, of course, squawked but the way Oracle claimed it left it with the court, before the judge’s decision, it would only assert patents that weren’t rejected by the PTO.
The claims upheld are part of US Patent No 5,966,702 on a “method and apparatus for pre-processing and packaging class files” and include 1, 5-7, 11-13, 15 and 16. Oracle only charged Google on claims 1, 6-7, 12, 13, 15 and 16.
Oracle’s got two patents left out of the seven it started with. It can’t assert the newly validated patent in any new litigation because it withdrew it with prejudice.
Published April 26, 2012 Reads 2,763
Copyright © 2012 SYS-CON Media, Inc. — All Rights Reserved.
Syndicated stories and blog feeds, all rights reserved by the author.
More Stories By Maureen O'Gara
Maureen O'Gara the most read technology reporter for the past 20 years, is the Cloud Computing and Virtualization News Desk editor of SYS-CON Media. She is the publisher of famous "Billygrams" and the editor-in-chief of "Client/Server News" for more than a decade. One of the most respected technology reporters in the business, Maureen can be reached by email at maureen(at)sys-con.com or paperboy(at)g2news.com, and by phone at 516 759-7025. Twitter: @MaureenOGara
- Cloud People: A Who's Who of Cloud Computing
- Cloud Expo New York: Cloud Is Changing the Economics of Business
- Windows Azure IaaS Reaches General Availability
- Cloudant to Exhibit at Cloud Expo & Big Data Expo New York
- Learn How To Use Google Apps Script
- Cloud Expo New York: Basics of SSD Technology and Its Use in Cloud
- Cloud Computing Is Simplifying Things
- Session Topics: 12th Cloud Expo / Cloud Expo New York
- Cloud Expo New York: The Big Challenge of Big Data & Hadoop Integration
- CollabNet And UC4 Announce General Availability Of Joint Enterprise DevOps Platform
- Overview of the OpenStack Cloud
- The Flexible Cloud
- Cloud People: A Who's Who of Cloud Computing
- Cloud Expo New York: Cloud Is Changing the Economics of Business
- Cloud Expo New York: How to Use Google Apps Script
- Windows Azure IaaS Reaches General Availability
- Rackspace Hosting Named “Platinum Plus Sponsor” of Cloud Expo New York
- Portable Experimenter’s Platform, Powered by Raspberry Pi
- Small Cancers, Big Data, and a Life Examined
- SUSE Receives Common Criteria Security Certifications
- Cloudant to Exhibit at Cloud Expo & Big Data Expo New York
- Basho Announces Open Source Riak CS and General Availability of Riak CS Enterprise v1.3
- Learn How To Use Google Apps Script
- Cloud Expo New York: Basics of SSD Technology and Its Use in Cloud
- After Ubuntu, Windows Looks Increasingly Bad, Increasingly Archaic, Increasingly Unfriendly
- SCO CEO Posts Open Letter to the Open Source Community
- Simula Labs Launches Hosted Delivery Platform To Enable Enterprise Open Source Adoption
- Where Are RIA Technologies Headed in 2008?
- Source Claims SCO Will Sue Google
- How Open Is "Open"? – Industry Luminaries Join the Debate
- Latest SCO News is Plain Weird
- SCO Claims Linux Lifted ELF
- IBM Tells SCO Court It Can't Find AIX-on-Power Code
- Developing an Application Using the Eclipse BIRT Report Engine API
- Should RIM BlackBerries Be Rented?
- Flashback: Investing in 'Professional Open Source' - Exclusive 2004 Interview with David Skok, Matrix Partners























