Welcome!

Open Source Cloud Authors: Elizabeth White, Pat Romanski, Greg Schulz, Carmen Gonzalez, Patrick Hubbard

Related Topics: Linux Containers

Linux Containers: Article

"SCO Admits It Mightn't Own Unix Exclusively," Argues Columbia's Professor Moglen

SCO is only suing Novell "to stay afloat," Eben Moglen says.

In his third paper on the long-running SCO-IBM-Novell-Linux saga, provocatively entitled "Now They Own It, Now They Don't: SCO Sues Novell to Stay Afloat," Columbia University law professor Eben Oglen grasps the nettle as always.

In his latest paper, available on the OSDL Web site, Professor Moglen makes the point that SCO "admits, by suing Novell, that its claim to exclusive ownership of the Unix copyright is in doubt."

"Now They Own It, Now They Don't: SCO Sues Novell to Stay Afloat" is available in PDF form here.

His argument is that no judge would hold an end user liable for intentionally infringing SCO Group's rights when SCO Group itself has cast doubt on what it owns and that - as a result - Linux customers have little incentive to purchase a license from SCO Group and instead can and will wait for a final decision on who owns the copyrights as between SCO Group and Novell.

Moglen makes a second point, too. Once the litigation is resolved, he maintains, and regardless of who prevails, customers will still have the right to use the Linux code in question without purchasing a license from either SCO Group or Novell.

Moglen points out that both SCO Group and Novell (who recently purchased SuSE Linux, a distributor of Linux) have distributed the Linux code under the GPL. Since the GPL allows licensees to use, modify, copy and distribute the Linux code freely, the results of the litigation will have no affect on those rights, and customers will have no obligation to purchase another license from either SCO Group or Novell to ensure those rights.

The report ends as follows:

"If SCO’s licensing campaign fails to generate the revenues SCO has been predicting for potential investors—because it turns out that SCO never owned what it claimed to be legally entitled to force others to license— SCO and its principals will have plenty to answer for, and not just to its shareholders, but to the SEC as well. It is not good practice to attempt to force people to buy from you what you may not own. It is even worse practice to mislead investors into thinking that they will benefit from such sales without disclosing that you may not own what you are trying to sell. Now that SCO itself has begun unraveling this aspect of the situation, the end is in sight. The winter of SCO’s discontent is likely to give way to a glorious summer for open source software."

[Editorial note: If the somewhat in-your-face title of the paper were not enough in itself to hint of Professor Moglen's predispositions, then a LinuxWorld reader points out that one needs always to bear in mind that Moglen's stated aim is: "Try to create freedom by destroying illegitimate power sheltered behind intellectual property law."]

 

More Stories By Jeremy Geelan

Jeremy Geelan is Chairman & CEO of the 21st Century Internet Group, Inc. and an Executive Academy Member of the International Academy of Digital Arts & Sciences. Formerly he was President & COO at Cloud Expo, Inc. and Conference Chair of the worldwide Cloud Expo series. He appears regularly at conferences and trade shows, speaking to technology audiences across six continents. You can follow him on twitter: @jg21.

Comments (11) View Comments

Share your thoughts on this story.

Add your comment
You must be signed in to add a comment. Sign-in | Register

In accordance with our Comment Policy, we encourage comments that are on topic, relevant and to-the-point. We will remove comments that include profanity, personal attacks, racial slurs, threats of violence, or other inappropriate material that violates our Terms and Conditions, and will block users who make repeated violations. We ask all readers to expect diversity of opinion and to treat one another with dignity and respect.


Most Recent Comments
Daniel Wallace 02/16/04 06:18:55 AM EST

When we examine the SCO v. Novell suit concerning
slander of title, we see the scoundrels in Utah, and
scoundrels they are, involved in more silly litigation...
except the implications of this litigation are far from
frivolous. The furor over SCO's disputed ownership of UNIX
and UnixWare copyrights may return to haunt Novell.

The asset purchase agreement between Novell and SCO
states:

"Schedule 1.1(a) Assets (Page 1 of 4)
1. All rights and ownership of UNIX and UnixWare,
including but not limited to all versions of UNIX and
UnixWare and all copies of UNIX and UnixWare (including
revisions and updates in process),..., including source
code,..."

Novell claims:
"Contrary to SCO's assertions, Amendment No. 2 does not
purport to concern "all copyrights pertaining to the UNIX
and UnixWare technologies." Instead, it concerns only the
unidentified rights that make up copyrights required for
Santa Cruz to exercise its rights with respect to the
acquisition of UNIX and UnixWare technologies. Not only
are those rights not identified, but SCO's "rights with
respect to the acquisition of UNIX and UnixWare
technologies" are identified. In the face of such vague
and ambiguous language, the governing authority is
clear: the purported assignment must be construed in favor
of the copyright holder and against a transfer of any
copyrights."

Huh?

Let's look at Novell's own words:
"... Instead, it concerns only the unidentified rights
that make up copyrights required for Santa Cruz to
exercise its rights with respect to the acquisition of
UNIX and UnixWare technologies."

Some terms:
acquisition --- The act of becoming the
owner of certain property;...
--- Black's Law Dictionary Fifth Edition.

"9.3 Interpretation.
When a reference is made in this Agreement to Schedules or
Exhibits, such reference shall be to a Schedule or Exhibit
to this Agreement unless otherwise indicated. The words
"include", "includes" and "including" when used herein
shall be deemed in each case to be followed by the words
"without limitation."..."

Novell's now words become:
"... Instead, it concerns only the unidentified rights
that make up copyrights required for Santa Cruz to
exercise its rights with respect to becoming the owner
of "All rights and ownership of UNIX and UnixWare,
including but not limited to all versions of UNIX and
UnixWare and all copies of UNIX and UnixWare (including
revisions and updates in process),..., including *without
limitation* source code,...".

We have now identified "which" source code:
... all versions of UNIX and UnixWare and all copies of
UNIX and UnixWare (including revisions and updates in
process)...".

We now know the "restrictions" placed on that source
code which we have identified:
"... including without limitation source code,...".

In case Novell cannot now identify these mysterious
"unidentified rights", I am willing to bet that a federal
judge can.

The asset purchase agreement is a statement of transfer of
ownership to all versions of UNIX and Unixware source code
copyrights.

It is not the "slander of title" action that is most
troublesome. Novell filed for registration with the
United States Copyright Office concerning copyrights on
the UNIX and UnixWare source code after knowingly
accepting ten million dollars from SCO's predecessors for
the purchase of all rights and ownership of UNIX and
UnixWare, including "without limitation" the source
code.

This act was done in an attempt to interfere with and
derail an otherwise frivolous copyright lawsuit. This act
has also ventured into the scope of federal civil and
criminal fraud statutes.

There is *no* SCO legal ownership interest in Linux source
code, so why is Novell handing SCO Novell's own head on a
platter?

Thank God I am a physicist and not a lawyer.

Tyler Jensen 02/15/04 02:12:44 PM EST

BSProtector writes:
>> If you are an attorney and you have a position, write a "position paper" and publish it. I'm sure people at Linux World will be glad to put it up. <<

I am not an attorney. Nearly made that mistake but at the last minute was saved from a life of boredom by the chance to intern for one.
I have nothing against lawyers or the practice of law, but let's try to get past the misguided reverence that so many of us "lay persons" have for the opinions of attorneys. I have many years of experience in software development but that does not make my opinions on the matter worthy of worship, and they are certainly slanted with my own bias and preferences. A healthly dose of skepticism and a solid footing on reason and common sense can take you a long way toward independent thought. Look at the motives behind a so-called "expert" opinion can help you sift through the rhetoric and come to your own conclusions. That is what the "disclosure" in this matter is all about. The editor's response to my original post validates this train of thought. I just wish so many other media outlets were as responsible as the LinuxWorld editors.

BSDProtector 02/11/04 10:15:04 PM EST

Tyler Jensen wrote:
>But I am getting rather tired of the press quoting Mr. Moglen as
>an expert on the subject without really disclosing his extreme bias in
>the matter. Consider his primary research aim: "Try to create freedom by
>destroying illegitimate power sheltered behind intellectual property law."

I have to agree with Mr Wallace here. What's there to disclose - he's the legal force behind FSF - everyone knows that (and it's written in footnote on page one of the paper). And, he's also a professor of law. Doesn't that doesn't make him an authority of some kind in legal matters?

If you are an attorney and you have a position, write a "position paper" and publish it. I'm sure people at Linux World will be glad to put it up.

As for the statement of Mr Moglen on the illegitimate powers of the intellectual property law, that's entirely debatable, of course.

Daniel Wallace 02/11/04 07:45:10 PM EST

"Unfortunately, I think, based on his comment, that Mr.
Wallace did not."

You are correct in saying that I did not grasp your point.

"But I am getting rather tired of the press quoting Mr.
Moglen as an expert on the subject without really
disclosing his extreme bias in the matter."

Does this imply the "liberal" press is somehow favoring
Mr. Moglen by not disclaiming his extreme bias?

I witnessed an article published this week in
LinuxWorld that could not have been considered anything
but extremely hostile to Mr. Moglen's views. That article
had about 12,000 reads. That doesn't imply to me, that at
least at the LinuxWorld press, that favoritism is being
accorded Mr. Moglen's views.

A Google search [ "intellectual property" moglen ] returns
5,110 hits. Mr. Moglen has become a highly visible public
figure. His views and biases against intellectual property
have been cross-linked throughout cyber-space and are
known to be virtually in lock-step with Richard Stallman
and the Free Software Foundation.

I do not think the press need re-iterate Mr. Moglen's
biases in reporting on his position papers and public
pronouncements concerning the FSF and SCO. To do so would
seemingly reinforce his credibility. Remember the saying
"repeat something often enough and it assumes an aura of
truth"?

Mr. Moglen has worked tirelessly as pro bono counsel
for a client and cause in which he believes. I admire
those motives in an attorney even though I may hold
countervailing views.

My "what's there to disclose?" was merely puzzlement
expressing "what hasn't already been publicly aired
concerning Mr. Moglen and his views?".

Tyler Jensen 02/11/04 06:45:22 PM EST

Throw a stone into a murder of crows huddled in the storm and see how they squawk and caterwaul. It is naive to believe that reading the filings on the SCO case on the groklaw site will lead you to the truth. Truth is not the objective of either side in this case. If you want the truth, go to church. If you want justice meted out as best that any flawed human system can hope to accomplish, then take your case to court in America. It is no insult to point out a person's self-stated beliefs and bias, but labeling anyone clueless without at least pointing to some supporting evidence seems to be not only insulting, but, well, clueless.

Tyler Jensen 02/11/04 05:34:25 PM EST

Thank you, LinuxWorld editors. I am glad that my point was taken correctly by you. Unfortunately, I think, based on his comment, that Mr. Wallace did not. Such a knee-jerk reaction is all too common in this debate, resulting more often than not in making the author of the comment appear fanatic, lacking the requisite deliberative intelligence to productively contribute. I'm sure that the FSF appreciates Mr. Moglen's service, but one does not have to leave his own site (http://emoglen.law.columbia.edu/) to form an opinion as to the personal motivation behind such service. And it is that specific information that I wish journalists would point out in their writing when quoting Mr. Moglen. I hope that clears up my meaning for anyone who did not grasp my point earlier.

Stormkrow 02/11/04 05:18:25 PM EST

It's okay to insult Moglen when he actually makes sense but not anyone else in this matter right? I think not; as much as SCO has been ramping things up in the press with all their FUD and not having a copyright to begin with is criminal in my opinion. By the way only 3 companies have paid for IP licenses; thats it 3. Why dont you, Mr Jensen take a peek at groklaw.net to actually learn what the TRUTH is and quit jumping on the band wagon with the rest of the cattle. By the way what about the oft quoted Ms.DiDio of Yankee Group? Now if you can find someone more clueless than her I'd like to see who they are (aside from Boies and McBride). And somehow she still has a high paying job. In my opinion whatever Ms. DiDio or McBride say then the complete opposite is true.
They can pry my Linux from my cold dead flippers.
Stormkrow

Daniel Wallace 02/11/04 04:46:32 PM EST

"But I am getting rather tired of the press quoting Mr. Moglen as an expert on the subject without really disclosing his extreme bias in the matter."

Professor Moglen is pro bono counsel for the Free Software
Foundation. I find it extremely gratifying to observe an
attorney upholding his Professional Code of Conduct by
zealously representing his client. To do less would be unethical. So what is there to disclose?

Fecal Extrusion 02/11/04 01:48:04 PM EST

Who is actually stupid enough to pay SCO a licensing fee for
the use of Linux?
And for whoever IS that stupid - are they likely to get
that money back "WHEN" SCO's case gets thrown out of court?

I think SCO should sue Microsoft instead, for misleading SCO
into believing that they actually stand a chance in court.

I'm sorry, but based on the rules of the GPL, if ANY judge
actually sides with SCO, then I'm afraid there really is
no such thing as Justice in America, and it is just as
USELESS as the US Patent office.

LinuxWorld editors 02/11/04 12:19:11 PM EST

A very fair point. We'll add this to the story, as it is clearly germane.

Tyler Jensen 02/11/04 12:13:28 PM EST

Mr. Moglen has spent far too much time in the classroom spouting his extremely liberal ideas about the law as judicial absolutes and not nearly enough time in the courtroom practicing the law before a judge required to consider both sides of an issue. Frankly, I think SCO's claims have weaknesses, as any such case would given the long and tangled history of the Unix IP. But I am getting rather tired of the press quoting Mr. Moglen as an expert on the subject without really disclosing his extreme bias in the matter. Consider his primary research aim: "Try to create freedom by destroying illegitimate power sheltered behind intellectual property law." (http://emoglen.law.columbia.edu/research-agenda.html) Read his agenda for yourself and then ask yourself why the press, itself a beneficiary of intellectual property law, does not disclose the bent of this oft quoted expert.

@ThingsExpo Stories
SYS-CON Events announced today that Cloudistics, an on-premises cloud computing company, has been named “Bronze Sponsor” of SYS-CON's 20th International Cloud Expo®, which will take place on June 6-8, 2017, at the Javits Center in New York City, NY. Cloudistics delivers a complete public cloud experience with composable on-premises infrastructures to medium and large enterprises. Its software-defined technology natively converges network, storage, compute, virtualization, and management into a ...
New competitors, disruptive technologies, and growing expectations are pushing every business to both adopt and deliver new digital services. This ‘Digital Transformation’ demands rapid delivery and continuous iteration of new competitive services via multiple channels, which in turn demands new service delivery techniques – including DevOps. In this power panel at @DevOpsSummit 20th Cloud Expo, moderated by DevOps Conference Co-Chair Andi Mann, panelists will examine how DevOps helps to meet th...
SYS-CON Events announced today that Progress, a global leader in application development, has been named “Bronze Sponsor” of SYS-CON's 20th International Cloud Expo®, which will take place on June 6-8, 2017, at the Javits Center in New York City, NY. Enterprises today are rapidly adopting the cloud, while continuing to retain business-critical/sensitive data inside the firewall. This is creating two separate data silos – one inside the firewall and the other outside the firewall. Cloud ISVs oft...
As cloud adoption continues to transform business, today's global enterprises are challenged with managing a growing amount of information living outside of the data center. The rapid adoption of IoT and increasingly mobile workforce are exacerbating the problem. Ensuring secure data sharing and efficient backup poses capacity and bandwidth considerations as well as policy and regulatory compliance issues.
SYS-CON Events announced today that A&I Solutions has been named “Bronze Sponsor” of SYS-CON's 20th International Cloud Expo®, which will take place on June 6-8, 2017, at the Javits Center in New York City, NY. Founded in 1999, A&I Solutions is a leading information technology (IT) software and services provider focusing on best-in-class enterprise solutions. By partnering with industry leaders in technology, A&I assures customers high performance levels across all IT environments including: ma...
SYS-CON Events announced today that Peak 10, Inc., a national IT infrastructure and cloud services provider, will exhibit at SYS-CON's 20th International Cloud Expo®, which will take place on June 6-8, 2017, at the Javits Center in New York City, NY. Peak 10 provides reliable, tailored data center and network services, cloud and managed services. Its solutions are designed to scale and adapt to customers’ changing business needs, enabling them to lower costs, improve performance and focus intern...
SYS-CON Events announced today that Linux Academy, the foremost online Linux and cloud training platform and community, will exhibit at SYS-CON's 20th International Cloud Expo®, which will take place on June 6-8, 2017, at the Javits Center in New York City, NY. Linux Academy was founded on the belief that providing high-quality, in-depth training should be available at an affordable price. Industry leaders in quality training, provided services, and student certification passes, its goal is to c...
SYS-CON Events announced today that CollabNet, a global leader in enterprise software development, release automation and DevOps solutions, will be a Bronze Sponsor of SYS-CON's 20th International Cloud Expo®, taking place from June 6-8, 2017, at the Javits Center in New York City, NY. CollabNet offers a broad range of solutions with the mission of helping modern organizations deliver quality software at speed. The company’s latest innovation, the DevOps Lifecycle Manager (DLM), supports Value S...
DevOps at Cloud Expo – being held October 31 - November 2, 2017, at the Santa Clara Convention Center in Santa Clara, CA – announces that its Call for Papers is open. Born out of proven success in agile development, cloud computing, and process automation, DevOps is a macro trend you cannot afford to miss. From showcase success stories from early adopters and web-scale businesses, DevOps is expanding to organizations of all sizes, including the world's largest enterprises – and delivering real r...
SYS-CON Events announced today that Systena America will exhibit at SYS-CON's 20th International Cloud Expo®, which will take place on June 6-8, 2017, at the Javits Center in New York City, NY. Systena Group has been in business for various software development and verification in Japan, US, ASEAN, and China by utilizing the knowledge we gained from all types of device development for various industries including smartphones (Android/iOS), wireless communication, security technology and IoT serv...
SYS-CON Events announced today that Cloud Academy will exhibit at SYS-CON's 20th International Cloud Expo®, which will take place on June 6-8, 2017, at the Javits Center in New York City, NY. Cloud Academy is the industry’s most innovative, vendor-neutral cloud technology training platform. Cloud Academy provides continuous learning solutions for individuals and enterprise teams for Amazon Web Services, Microsoft Azure, Google Cloud Platform, and the most popular cloud computing technologies. Ge...
SYS-CON Events announced today that Fusion, a leading provider of cloud services, will exhibit at SYS-CON's 20th International Cloud Expo®, which will take place on June 6-8, 2017, at the Javits Center in New York City, NY. Fusion, a leading provider of integrated cloud solutions to small, medium and large businesses, is the industry’s single source for the cloud. Fusion’s advanced, proprietary cloud service platform enables the integration of leading edge solutions in the cloud, including cloud...
Five years ago development was seen as a dead-end career, now it’s anything but – with an explosion in mobile and IoT initiatives increasing the demand for skilled engineers. But apart from having a ready supply of great coders, what constitutes true ‘DevOps Royalty’? It’ll be the ability to craft resilient architectures, supportability, security everywhere across the software lifecycle. In his keynote at @DevOpsSummit at 20th Cloud Expo, Jeffrey Scheaffer, GM and SVP, Continuous Delivery Busine...
SYS-CON Events announced today that Interoute has been named “Bronze Sponsor” of SYS-CON's 20th International Cloud Expo®, which will take place on June 6-8, 2017, at the Javits Center in New York City, NY. Interoute is the owner operator of Europe's largest network and a global cloud services platform, which encompasses over 70,000 km of lit fiber, 15 data centers, 17 virtual data centers and 33 colocation centers, with connections to 195 additional partner data centers. Our full-service Unifie...
SYS-CON Events announced today that Ocean9will exhibit at SYS-CON's 20th International Cloud Expo®, which will take place on June 6-8, 2017, at the Javits Center in New York City, NY. Ocean9 provides cloud services for Backup, Disaster Recovery (DRaaS) and instant Innovation, and redefines enterprise infrastructure with its cloud native subscription offerings for mission critical SAP workloads.
Internet of @ThingsExpo, taking place October 31 - November 2, 2017, at the Santa Clara Convention Center in Santa Clara, CA, is co-located with the 21st International Cloud Expo and will feature technical sessions from a rock star conference faculty and the leading industry players in the world. @ThingsExpo Silicon Valley Call for Papers is now open.
SYS-CON Events announced today that Enzu will exhibit at SYS-CON's 20th International Cloud Expo®, which will take place on June 6-8, 2017, at the Javits Center in New York City, NY, and the 21st International Cloud Expo®, which will take place October 31-November 2, 2017, at the Santa Clara Convention Center in Santa Clara, CA. Enzu’s mission is to be the leading provider of enterprise cloud solutions worldwide. Enzu enables online businesses to use its IT infrastructure to their competitive ad...
Everywhere we turn in our industry we can find strong opinions about the direction, type and nature of cloud’s impact on computing and business. Another word that is used in every context in our industry is “hybrid.” In his session at 20th Cloud Expo, Alvaro Gonzalez, Director of Technical, Partner and Field Marketing at Peak 10, will use a combination of a few conceptual props and some research recently commissioned by Peak 10 to offer a real-world consideration of how the various categories of...
SYS-CON Events announced today that SoftLayer, an IBM Company, has been named “Gold Sponsor” of SYS-CON's 18th Cloud Expo, which will take place on June 7-9, 2016, at the Javits Center in New York, New York. SoftLayer, an IBM Company, provides cloud infrastructure as a service from a growing number of data centers and network points of presence around the world. SoftLayer’s customers range from Web startups to global enterprises.
Multiple data types are pouring into IoT deployments. Data is coming in small packages as well as enormous files and data streams of many sizes. Widespread use of mobile devices adds to the total. In this power panel at @ThingsExpo, moderated by Conference Chair Roger Strukhoff, panelists will look at the tools and environments that are being put to use in IoT deployments, as well as the team skills a modern enterprise IT shop needs to keep things running, get a handle on all this data, and deli...