YOUR FEEDBACK
Tim FitzGerald wrote: As an HP distributor who specializes in virtualization solutions, we view these...
AJAXWorld RIA Conference
$300 Savings Expire September 5th. Register Today and SAVE!


2008 East
DIAMOND SPONSOR:
Data Direct
Frontiers in Data Access: The Coming Wave in Data Services
PLATINUM SPONSORS:
Red Hat
The Opening of Virtualization
Intel
Virtualization – Path to Predictive Enterprise
Green Hills
IT Security in a Hostile World
JBoss / freedom oss
Practical SOA Approach
GOLD SPONSORS:
Software AG
The Art & Science of SOA: How Governance Enables Adoption
PlateSpin
Effective Planning for Virtual Infrastructure Growth
Fujitsu
Automated Business Process Discovery & Virtualization Service
Ceedo
Workspace Virtualization
Click For 2007 West
Event Webcasts

2008 East
PLATINUM SPONSORS:
Appcelerator
Think Fast: Accelerate AJAX Development with Appcelerator
GOLD SPONSORS:
DreamFace Interactive
The Ultimate Framework for Creating Personalized Web 2.0 Mashups
ICEsoft
AJAX and Social Computing for the Enterprise
Kaazing
Enterprise Comet: Real–Time, Real–Time, or Real–Time Web 2.0?
Nexaweb
Now Playing: Desktop Apps in the Browser!
Sun
jMaki as an AJAX Mashup Framework
POWER PANELS:
The Business Value
of RIAs
What Lies Beyond AJAX?
KEYNOTES:
Douglas Crockford
Can We Fix the Web?
Anthony Franco
2008: The Year of the RIA
Click For 2007 Event Webcasts
SYS-CON.TV
TOP LINKS YOU MUST CLICK ON


Commercial Packages vs Open Source: Which is Better Long-term?
As a software integrator, my experience makes me very wary of open source

MySQL is one of the positive examples of open source. However, I find that far too many people go for open source due to short term advantages (e.g., it is free), without adequate consideration of the full cost/benefit considerations and the long term implications.

To begin with, to a certain extent you get what you pay for. If the package is free, then the support and service is going to be limited as there is no funding for it. Not many people would buy a commercial package with no guaranteed support, so likewise they should carefully consider this for open source.


Secondly, although packages such as MySQL have a large development and user community, many other open source packages have a limited development community. Often the development and support community is largely driven and organised by a single individual or small group of individuals. When these people move on, even though the design community may still exist, the driving force to make it effective is lost. This is much less likely with a commercially successful package, which is protected by past financial investment and commercial commitments and future revenue streams. When looking at open source, one must ensure that the support and development community is sufficiently large and diverse that this is not an issue.

One also needs to consider the purchase price savings, in light both of the total cost of the project and in light of potential risks. A hypothetical example: an open source accounting package for free or a commercial one for $10000. The former provides a substantial day-1 saving. However, if one has 3 staff using the package full time (moderately large company) to input information then the labour costs alone are about $300 000 per year. So the $10 000 saving is trivial in the bigger picture. A commercial package which has a 5% more efficient interface will more than pay for itself in less than a year on labour cost savings alone. Also, support and documention limitations typically asssociated with open source can easily cost more than the initial savings.

As a software integrator, my experience makes me very wary of open source. There are of course noteable exceptions (such as MySQL). However, in most cases I find that commercial packages are a better long-term business decision than open source.

I'm also wary of people why say they they will try open source and if it doesn't work out they will switch to a commercial package. Although this is possible, the costs of migrating data, changing procedures and modifying interfaces to other software can be prohibitive.

Am I'm being overly negative about open source? Perhaps so. However, it is a reaction to the overly optimistic and naive approach that I often see to this subject.

About Doug Stewart
Doug Stewart is Director of French Property, Services and Information Ltd. (www.france-property-and-information.com).

ENTERPRISE OPEN SOURCE MAGAZINE LATEST STORIES . . .
Alfresco Software announced that Adobe has implemented Alfresco’s document sharing and collaboration capabilities as part of the file sharing features in Acrobat.com. Adobe chose Alfresco as its content repository for its clustered high-availability, security, and highly capable tec...
Open Systems has announced that TRAVERSE v10.5 has been certified to run on Microsoft's SQL Server 2008 database server. SQL Server 2008 promises a dynamic platform for business-critical applications and enterprise-class data management, and is available in seven editions, ranging from...
qooxdoo is a comprehensive and innovative AJAX application framework. Leveraging object-oriented JavaScript allows developers to build cross-browser applications. No HTML, CSS or DOM knowledge is needed. It includes a platform-independent development tool chain, a state-of-the-art GUI ...
Three-letter acronyms (TLAs) are hardly new in Information Technology: EAI, ESB, SOA, BPM, BAM, ETL, MDM; the list goes on and on. This article is about yet another three-letter acronym, EDA, which stands for Event-Driven Architecture. EDA is not a brand new technology, but rather a pr...
Imagine the CIO of a consumer bank who thinks he is running 50 Oracle databases, but now finds out that in fact he has 100 databases installed behind his firewall. He doesn't have any idea where the other 50 came from. He doesn’t know the name of the vendor(s) supporting them. And he...
I was shocked. We were in the brainstorming phase of developing a new collaboration portal and the possibilities were flying. It was exciting to see people from many disciplines enthusiastic about working together more effectively through improved communication, document management, an...
SUBSCRIBE TO THE WORLD'S MOST POWERFUL NEWSLETTERS
SUBSCRIBE TO OUR RSS FEEDS & GET YOUR SYS-CON NEWS LIVE!
Click to Add our RSS Feeds to the Service of Your Choice:
Google Reader or Homepage Add to My Yahoo! Subscribe with Bloglines Subscribe in NewsGator Online
myFeedster Add to My AOL Subscribe in Rojo Add 'Hugg' to Newsburst from CNET News.com Kinja Digest View Additional SYS-CON Feeds
Publish Your Article! Please send it to editorial(at)sys-con.com!

Advertise on this site! Contact advertising(at)sys-con.com! 201 802-3021


SYS-CON FEATURED WHITEPAPERS

ADS BY GOOGLE